Mattress Firm – Best Mattress Prices
When it comes to mattress firmness, everyone has their preference. If you’re a back sleeper, stomach sleeper, or tend to suffer from aches and pains, you may prefer sleeping on a mattress that provides more support, but still has a high degree of comfort.
If you’re in the market for a mattress that offers good support for your core, back, and hips, and also scores high for comfort, there are plenty of firmer options to choose from.
Not sure where to start? No problem. We’ve rounded up 10 of the best Mattress Firm of Mattresses 2021 to help you figure out which mattress may be a good choice for you.
The Best Firm Mattresses of 2021
A firm mattress supports your body weight and gives a feeling of sleeping on top of the mattress. Softer mattresses can provide a hugging sensation because you sink down into them. Because of this, firm mattresses can be better for people who tend to sleep hot. Firm mattress types include innerspring, latex, foam, and hybrid. Often, foam mattresses are engineered for specific firmnesses.
Some memory foam mattresses, such as the Saatva Loom & Leaf, are infused with cooling gels and use a body-conforming layer of memory foam for extra comfort. Other mattresses come with optional firmness levels like soft, medium, and firm. The Saatva Classic is a good example. It has plush-soft, luxury firm, and firm options. This lets you pick the firmness that matches the amount of support you need.
Your most comfortable sleeping position can help you decide which mattress firmness is best for you. The Tempur-Pedic Tempur-ProAdapt and the Tempur-Luxebreeze are foam mattresses that are available in a firm feel, which may be good for stomach sleepers.
If you’re a side sleeper or a combination sleeper who rotates between your side and your stomach, you’ll likely prefer something softer. A bed with overly firm support won’t give underneath your shoulders and hips, which leaves your spine in an awkward position when you lay on your side. A good compromise is to opt for a medium-firm mattress such as the Saatva Classic Mattress.
Saatva Classic - Best-rated firm mattress
Key features: The Saatva Classic Mattress earns our top spot for best-rated firm mattress for several reasons. It continually receives high praises from its customers, you can customize the firmness of your mattress, and it’s made in the USA.
With three firmness options to choose from including plush soft (soft), luxury-firm (medium), and firm, you will get the mattress you want with no difference in quality or cost.
Considerations: If you want a traditional innerspring mattress with a plush pillow top feel, this bed fits the bill. But if you’re looking for a true memory foam mattress, this may not be the right choice for you.
Both the luxury-firm and firm mattresses can accommodate most sleeping positions. However, they may not be the best option if you are a true side sleeper since this level of firmness may not provide enough pressure relief when sleeping on your side.
Plank by Brooklyn Bedding - Best extra-firm mattress
Key features: The Plank by Brooklyn Bedding gives you the freedom to choose your level of firmness, even after you bring the bed home. Designed as a flippable mattress, each side has a different firmness. One side ranks as an 8 on the firmness scale, and the other side a 10, or extra firm.
If you tend to get warm when you sleep, you can add an optional cooling top panel for an additional $200.
Considerations: This mattress is very firm and may be too firm for some people. More specifically, it is not ideal for side sleepers, people who need sharp pressure point relief, or if you wake easily when your partner moves around.
Helix Twilight LUXE - Best firm mattress for side sleepers
Key features: If you’re a side sleeper who’s looking for a medium-firm mattress that provides pressure point relief for your hips and shoulders, this bed delivers the goods.
Designed as a hybrid mattress with five layers of foam and wrapped coils, it also comes with a premium quilted pillow top and a breathable cover made out of a jersey material. Plus, according to many customers, it passes the motion transfer test, which means it’s a great choice for couples.
Considerations: The Helix Twilight LUXE sleeps cool, so if you tend to dress head-to-toe for bed, you may find this mattress a little on the cold side.
Casper Original - Best firm mattress for low back pain
Key features: If you have low back pain, but don’t want to spend a ton of money on a mattress, the Casper may be a good option. The Casper is a medium-firm mattress with three layers of foam that works for side, stomach, and back sleepers.
Dr. Allen Conrad, BS, DC, CSCS, of Montgomery County Chiropractic Center, says several of his patients with low back pain experience relief when sleeping on the Casper. His clinic recommends it for side sleepers due to its reinforced lumbar cushioning.
“The Casper, with its reinforced support zones in the shoulder and low back regions, helps people who sleep on their side avoid spinal compression,” he explained.
Considerations: The edge support on the Casper is not the best. And while this may not be a deal-breaker for some, if you like to sit or sleep on the edge of the bed, it may sag more than you’d like.
Nectar Memory Foam - Best firm lower-cost mattress
Key features: If you don’t want to spend a thousand dollars or more on a mattress, the Nectar Memory Foam is a great option. Simple and affordable, this five-layer, medium-firm mattress is an excellent choice for most sleep styles.
The Nectar lands right in the middle of the firmness scale, which means it offers an ideal ratio of firmness and softness. It’s also a good option for hot sleepers since the quilted memory foam is designed to be breathable. Most notably, side sleepers will appreciate the pressure relief at the shoulders and hips.
Considerations: Stomach sleepers may experience low back pain with this mattress. If you need extra support for your hips, you may want to consider a firmer mattress.
DreamCloud Luxury Hybrid - Best firm pillow-top mattress
Key features: Designed for all sleep positions, this medium/luxury-firm mattress combines gel-infused memory foam with individual encased coils to help optimize pressure point support. The cashmere blend Quilted Euro Top is a selling point if you’re looking for a firm mattress that offers pillow-top comfort. It’s also a top pick among hybrid mattresses.
Considerations: The extra cushioning and comfort of a pillow-top can provide extra support for heavier people, but if you’re on the lighter side and want to feel as if the bed “hugs” you, you may want to consider a different mattress.
What Is a Firm Mattress?
A firm mattress is a mattress that scores higher on the firmness scale. The firmness scale ranges from one to 10, with firm mattresses typically placing at eight and above. The higher the number, the more the mattress can support your body weight, which is why firmer mattresses tend to be better for larger or heavier people. Mattresses that are softer can give you a feeling of sinking into the bed instead of sleeping on top.
The firmness feel of a mattress is subjective. It varies depending on the individual. For that reason, many manufacturers offer optional levels of firmness or multiple mattress lines so that you can customize your comfort and the amount of support you need. If you choose a mattress that has a risk-free sleep trial period, you have an opportunity to exchange the mattress for a different firmness level if necessary.
How to Buy a Firm Mattress
There are several important factors when purchasing a firm mattress. In addition to the firmness level, consider any allergies you may have, how sensitive you are to mattress smell, and other health issues. Some brands use eco-friendly or certified organic materials, while others use chemicals that are known to emit odors, especially at first. Some mattresses offer more or thicker layers, which can ultimately lead to more comfortable nights – as long as they properly support your back.
Keep these things in mind while you’re shopping for your next firm mattress:
- Mattress type: Foam mattresses performed the best this year in our firm mattress ratings. That said, innerspring and hybrid mattresses can also be good firm mattresses depending on how they’re made.
- Materials: Nontoxic, eco-friendly materials are often more expensive but can also be better for your allergies. Individuals who are sensitive to chemical smells will appreciate that these materials typically have less off-gassing odors. Learn more about natural materials in our guide to the Best Organic Mattresses.
- Sleeping position: Consider your preferred sleeping position when thinking about the firmness level. A firmer feel tends to be more comfortable if you sleep primarily on your back or stomach. Combination sleepers and side sleepers will likely find an extra-firm mattress uncomfortable, as these can put pressure on your shoulders and hips, and don’t always properly align your spine.
- Back pain: Most individuals with back pain find that a mattress that’s firm or medium-firm helps alleviate pain at night. Comfort is highly subjective, however, so it’s important to get a mattress that you personally find to be supportive and relaxing, rather than just defaulting to a firm mattress. Learn more in our guide to the Best Mattresses for Back Pain.
- New mattress warranties: A new mattress warranty can indicate its expected lifetime and can also hint at its quality. Warranties are generally around 10-20 years, with a few brands offering lifetime warranties. Read the fine print though, because often the second half of a 20-year warranty can come with strings attached. For example, reimbursement under a 20-year warranty is sometimes prorated after year 10.
- Sleep trial periods: A sleep trial gives you a chance to try the mattress in the comfort of your own home. Lots of brands offer trial periods ranging around 100-120 days, but some are only 10 days, and some are a full year. For best results, look for a mattress that comes with a minimum sleep trial period of 30 days.
- Box or white-glove delivery: Make sure you know how your mattress will be delivered before you place your order. Some mattresses come in a box and unfold easily when removed from the packaging. Some brands offer white-glove delivery for easy set-up of your new mattress (and possible removal of your old one). This usually costs $100 or so, though some brands offer it for free.
- Return policies: It’s nice to make sure you have the option to return your mattress, which can reduce the risk of such a high-dollar purchase. Different brands have different return policies but often can send someone to pick it up and discard or donate it for you.
How Much Does a Firm Mattress Cost?
The firm mattresses in our comparison cost between $930 and $2,999. The price depends on the mattress size and type, as well as the number of features. For a higher price, you get a more upscale mattress that can have options ranging from more firmness choices to thicker layers of foam or even eco-friendly materials.For an upscale firm foam mattress, the Tempur-Pedic Tempur-ProAdapt starts at $2,499 for a twin size and $2,999 for a queen. It’s available in a full range of sizes, with its range-topping split California king retailing for about $4,998. If you want to prioritize your wallet on your next mattress purchase, visit our Cheapest Mattresses of 2021 ratings.
Firm Mattresses for Back Pain
Firm mattresses can be comfortable if you suffer from back pain, as they provide good support for your back and properly align your spine. An ultra-firm mattress isn’t relaxing for everyone, though, especially if you sleep on your side. A medium-firm mattress can also be good for your back, and many will appreciate the additional relief for pressure points from a cushier top layer.
Our rating of the Best Mattresses for Back Pain contains mattresses that are available in a medium-firm or firmer feel. In the No. 1 spot is the Casper Wave Hybrid, followed by the Saatva Classic, and the Purple Mattress. The Saatva Classic is available in multiple firmness levels, including firm. Casper and Purple don’t list mattress firmness levels.
If you are a back pain sufferer and want to learn more about how a different mattress can help, check out our Best Mattresses for Back Pain ratings.
Other Mattress Types to Consider
A firm mattress can be made from a variety of materials such as foam, innersprings, latex, or a combination of foam and innersprings. Hybrid mattresses can provide the best of both worlds with a firm and supportive coil-on-coil layer paired with a soft comfort layer for pressure-point relief. Learn more about other mattress types in our mattress guides. We also cover general ownership issues, like how long you can expect your new mattress to last or where to get rid of your old one.